Sullivan & Cromwell LLP Logo
  • Home
  • Lawyers
  • Practices
  • Insights
  • About
  • Careers
  • Alumni
  • Twitter icon
  • LinkedIn icon
  •  icon
  • Podcasts icon
© 2025 Sullivan & Cromwell LLP
    • Home
    • Lawyers
    • Practices
    • Insights
    • About
    • Careers
    • Alumni
    Home /  About /  News And Events /  Client Highlights
    Client Highlights

    S&C Wins Key Ruling for JPMorgan on Syndicated Loans

    • Our Lawyers
    • Related Practices
    October 8, 2021

    S&C obtained a ruling for client JPMorgan Chase that a syndicated term loan should not be treated as a “security” under state securities (Blue Sky) laws. In granting JPMorgan’s motion to dismiss on May 22, 2020, District Judge Paul Gardephe of the Southern District of New York found that the limited number of highly sophisticated lenders in this transaction would not consider the term loan a security.

    The Loan Syndications and Trading Association and the Bank Policy Institute filed an amicus brief in support of JPMorgan, stressing that “treating syndicated term loans as securities would devastate a trillion-dollar-plus market that is vital to the economy.”

    In April 2014, JPMorgan led a group of banks that arranged a $1.775 billion term loan for Millennium Laboratories, a drug-testing company, which was syndicated to roughly 70 institutional investor groups comprised of mutual funds, hedge funds, and other institutional investors. In November 2015, after settling with the Department of Justice over its billing practices, Millennium filed for bankruptcy court protection. A trustee appointed by the bankruptcy court sued JPMorgan and the other banks that arranged the loan. The trustee claimed that when marketing the loan, the banks misrepresented or omitted material facts about the legality of Millennium’s sales, marketing, and billing practices, as well as the risks posed by the government investigation.

    The S&C team, which took the lead on briefing the motion to dismiss for all defendants, argued that the loan was not a security under the Supreme Court’s precedent in Reves and the Second Circuit’s decision in Banco Espanol. Judge Gardephe accepted this argument, finding that “it would have been reasonable for these sophisticated institutional buyers to believe that they were lending money, with all of the risks that may entail, and without the disclosure and other protections associated with the issuance of securities.” Judge Gardephe also dismissed the trustee’s claims for negligent misrepresentation, breach of fiduciary duty, breach of contract and breach of the covenant of good faith.

    On September 30, 2021, Judge Gardephe denied the trustee’s motion for leave to file an amended complaint asserting three new claims (common law fraud, aiding and abetting fraud, conspiracy to commit fraud), and reasserting his claim for negligent misrepresentation. Judge Gardephe found that the trustee had not adequately alleged that JPMorgan “controlled, authorized, or caused” Millennium’s allegedly false statements or that it had directly made false statements. On the trustee’s secondary fraud claims, Judge Gardephe found that the plaintiff failed to plead the defendants’ “direct and active participation” in the fraud, for the purposes of aiding and abetting liability. Nor did the trustee adequately plead conspiracy. Finally, with respect to negligent misrepresentation, Judge Gardephe found that contractual disclaimers precluded a duty of care.

    Christopher Viapiano and Ann-Elizabeth Ostrager led the S&C team representing JPMorgan.

    Read More
    Stay Updated

    Subscribe to stay current on S&C Insights.

    Our Lawyers

    Our Lawyers

    Ann-Elizabeth Ostrager Headshot Photo
    Ann-Elizabeth Ostrager
    New York
    +1-212-558-7357
    Email
    vCard
    Christopher Michael Viapiano Headshot Photo
    Christopher Michael Viapiano
    Washington, D.C.
    +1-202-956-7500
    Email
    vCard
    Read More

    Related Practices

    • Litigation
    • Securities Litigation
    Sullivan & Cromwell LLP Logo
    • Twitter icon
    • LinkedIn icon
    • RSS Feed icon
    • Podcasts icon
    • Home
    • Contact Us
    • Information Policy Relating to Cookies
    • Privacy Policy
    • California Privacy Policy
    • Website Notice
    • Attorney Advertising Notice
    © 2025 Sullivan & Cromwell LLP