Sullivan & Cromwell LLP Logo
  • Home
  • Lawyers
  • Practices
  • Insights
  • About
  • Careers
  • Alumni
  • Client
© 2023 Sullivan & Cromwell LLP
    Home /  About /  News And Events /  Client Highlights
    Client Highlights

    S&C Prevails for Volkswagen in Ninth Circuit Ruling on Sales Commissions

    • Our Lawyers
    • Related Practices
    December 20, 2021

    Volkswagen and its affiliates prevailed before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit when the court affirmed the dismissal with prejudice of all claims brought by a putative class of current and former Volkswagen dealer salespeople related to Volkswagen’s diesel issues. The December 6 ruling followed oral arguments on November 18.

    Plaintiffs sought to recover allegedly lost commissions and other income from reduced demand at Volkswagen dealerships following the 2015 public disclosure of Volkswagen’s diesel issue. In their appeal, the plaintiffs claimed that Volkswagen should be responsible for purported California wage and hour law violations based on a theory that Volkswagen should be deemed their joint employers with the dealers. This unprecedented joint employment theory, if adopted, would have created a harmful precedent for auto manufacturers and franchisors more generally.

    Judge Charles Breyer of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California previously dismissed plaintiffs’ complaint three times for failure to state any plausible claim. In the earlier dismissals, the judge also held that the plaintiffs had failed to allege sufficient facts to support claims that Volkswagen negligently interfered with their prospective economic advantage, breached terms of a sales incentive program and violated RICO.

    In ruling on the California wage and hour law claims, the Ninth Circuit held that plaintiffs did not plausibly allege that Volkswagen AG or Volkswagen Group of America was their joint employer. Among other things, the Ninth Circuit held that the plaintiffs failed to adequately allege that Volkswagen exercised control over their wages, hours, or working conditions or controlled how they sold cars.

    The team representing Volkswagen includes Bob Giuffra, Sharon Nelles, Bill Monahan, Andrew Finn (who argued the appeal), Sverker Högberg, Lauren Goldsmith and Jonathan Blevins.

    Read More
    Stay Updated

    Subscribe to stay current on S&C Insights.

    Our Lawyers

    Our Lawyers

    Robert J. Giuffra Jr. Headshot Photo
    Robert J. Giuffra Jr.
    New York
    +1-212-558-3121
    Email
    vCard
    Sharon L. Nelles Headshot Photo
    Sharon L. Nelles
    New York
    +1-212-558-4000
    Email
    vCard
    William B. Monahan Headshot Photo
    William B. Monahan
    New York
    +1-212-558-7375
    Email
    vCard
    Andrew J. Finn Headshot Photo
    Andrew J. Finn
    New York
    +1-212-558-4000
    Email
    vCard
    Sverker K. Hogberg Headshot Photo
    Sverker K. Hogberg
    Palo Alto
    +1-650-461-5600
    Email
    vCard
    Lauren M. Goldsmith Headshot Photo
    Lauren M. Goldsmith
    New York
    +1-212-558-4000
    Email
    vCard
    Sverker K. Hogberg Headshot Photo
    Sverker K. Hogberg
    Palo Alto
    +1-650-461-5600
    Email
    vCard
    Read More

    Related Practices

    • Consumer & Retail
    • Crisis Management
    • Labor & Employment
    • Litigation
    • Products Liability & Mass Torts
    • Supreme Court and Appellate
    Sullivan & Cromwell LLP Logo
    • Twitter icon
    • LinkedIn icon
    • RSS Feed icon
    • Podcasts icon
    • Home
    • Contact Us
    • Sitemap
    • Information Policy Relating to Cookies
    • Privacy Policy
    • California Privacy Policy
    • Website Notice
    • Attorney Advertising Notice
    © 2023 Sullivan & Cromwell LLP